Published 11/19/2026
The 1031 Brief Podcast Ep. 7: Can You Seller Finance a Property and Still Do a 1031 Exchange?
Seller financing can help bridge a financing gap, expand the pool of potential buyers, or give buyers and sellers more flexibility in a real estate transaction. But when the seller is also planning a 1031 exchange, a seller carryback note creates another question: where does that note fit into the exchange? In this episode of The 1031 Brief, Ashley Stefan breaks down seller financing in plain English, including why buyers and sellers use it, how installment sale concepts may come into play, and the choices an investor should understand when seller financing and a 1031 exchange overlap.
Check out the Seller Financing FAQ.
Listen to the episode on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
TRANSCRIPT
Ashley Stefan: Imagine you're selling an investment property for $2 million. You've got a buyer, you've agreed on the price, the deal is basically done. But after all is said and done, the buyer's lender is only willing to finance enough to get them to $1.7 million. What to do about that $300,000 gap?
The seller could lower the price, or maybe the buyer is able to find another source of cash. Or the seller could say, I'll finance the last $300,000 myself. The buyer can close on the purchase, the seller gets the price they negotiated, and instead of receiving all cash at closing, the seller walks away with cash plus a promissory note that the buyer will be paying over time. That's broadly referred to as seller financing. But now let's add another fact.
The seller is doing a 1031 exchange. As we've discussed in the past, where a QI is involved, any funds included in the exchange must be sent to that QI at closing. But what happens to this $300,000 note? Can it be part of the exchange? Does the seller keep it? Can it somehow be turned into cash? And what happens if the seller is relying on that money to buy the replacement property? That's what we're talking about today.
Welcome to The 1031 Brief, a podcast from First American Exchange Company. I'm Ashley Stefan. On this podcast, we break down real estate, tax, and 1031 exchange concepts in plain English so investors and advisors have enough information to ask the right questions before a deal gets too far along.
Before we get started, a quick reminder as usual that this podcast is for educational purposes only. It's not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice. Every investor's facts are different, so please consult your tax advisor and legal counsel about your particular investment details.
Today, we're talking about seller financing. You may also hear this called a seller carry back note or seller carry back financing. And I want to start outside the 1031 world for a minute because seller financing is first and foremost a real estate financing tool. Once we understand why somebody might use it, the exchange piece will make a lot more sense.
So first, we have to answer the question, what does seller financing actually mean?
At its simplest, seller financing means the seller agrees to receive some portion of the purchase price later. Normally, imagine you're buying a property and the seller wants a million dollars. You might put in $250,000 of your own money. Your lender brings in the other $750,000. The seller gets paid at closing and moves on. They see a million dollars in proceeds. Seller financing changes that equation. Maybe the bank will only lend $650,000 and the buyer is still only able to bring in two hundred and fifty thousand. That leaves a $100,000 gap. The seller could agree to carry that last $100,000, but what does that mean? Instead of receiving that amount in cash at closing, the seller receives a promissory note from the buyer, and the note says in basic terms: buyer owes seller this money, here's the interest rate, here's how it will be paid, how much and for how long, and here's when the balance is due.
Depending on the deal, the note may be secured by the real estate with a deed of trust or a mortgage. So the seller has sold the property, but the financial relationship between the buyer and seller isn't necessarily over in these situations. The seller has effectively become one of the buyer's lenders. And that's the first thing I think investors should really understand. Seller financing isn't just another line on the settlement statement, reflecting a source of funds. As the seller, the investor is agreeing to get paid later. They're taking on some amount of credit risk. So the terms matter and should always be discussed with an attorney or tax advisor. How long will the loan run? Will the buyer make monthly principal and interest payments? What's securing the debt? What happens if the buyer doesn't pay?
Those aren't 1031 related questions, they're lending and real estate questions that the seller should be thinking through with their appropriate advisors before agreeing to the financing arrangement. But this example shows how deal nuances unconnected to Section 1031 of the code can affect the overall exchange transaction.
Now, why exactly would a buyer or seller want to choose to do seller financing? There are a lot of reasons that this comes up. Let's start with the buyer. Maybe conventional financing doesn't cover the entire purchase price. Perhaps the buyer and seller are trying to get a transaction closed more quickly without traditional lender hurdles and time frames. Or the parties might simply find terms that work better for this particular transaction where payments are made over time.
Seller financing can create flexibility, and that can be especially meaningful when lending conditions are tighter or properties don't fit neatly inside conventional underwriting. For the seller, there can be advantages too. For example, offering seller financing might broaden the pool of potential buyers. It could help bridge a gap between the buyer's available financing and the price the seller actually wants.
And depending on the terms, the seller could possibly be receiving interest income from the note over time. There's also a concept that can come into play called an installment sale.
We're not going to turn this into an installment sale tax episode because that's really a conversation for the investor and their CPA, but the basic concept is worth understanding. When a seller receives at least some of the purchase price in a later tax year, they could qualify, depending on the facts, to recognize some of the gain as payments are received, rather than recognizing the entire gain in the year of the sale.
There are, of course, exceptions. Depreciation, recapture, and interest have their own rules as well. So again, the investor-specific tax result needs to come from that investor and their tax advisor. But here's the concept to remember: seller financing already has its own tax consequences before we ever add a 1031 exchange to the mix. And sometimes seller financing and a 1031 exchange show up in the same transaction. So that's where the planning gets more interesting.
Let's talk now about actually adding in the exchange element. Let's go back to our original example. The property sells for $2 million. The buyer pays $1.7 million in cash and third-party financing dollars at closing and gives the $300,000 note for the balance. The seller wants to complete a 1031 exchange. The first question I would want to ask that investor is: where is the $300,000 note going? There are basically two broad paths to think about.
The note can stay outside of the exchange, or the investor can explore whether the note can be structured inside the exchange. And that choice affects what happens next. So let's take them one at a time.
The simpler concept is where the buyer gives the seller the note directly. The qualified intermediary receives the cash exchange proceeds. The seller receives the promissory note.
That note isn't being treated as part of the exchange proceeds held by the QI. Instead, the seller and their tax advisor would evaluate how the note is treated for tax purposes, including whether installment sale treatment may apply, but the value wouldn't be eligible for tax deferral within the 1031 exchange. So you can have one real estate sale creating two different tax planning tracks. Part of the consideration may be moving through a 1031 exchange.
Another part may be represented by seller financing held directly by the seller, with payments being made and gains recognized over time. This is where planning with your tax and legal team matters. If that $300,000 was money the investor intended to use toward their next investment property, then receiving a note instead of cash changes the economics of the replacement purchase. The investor may have $300,000 less cash available to close, and there may be more gain recognized more quickly over time than they had originally planned. Which brings us to the other path.
Sometimes the investor wants the seller financing note to be part of the 1031 exchange. That can be possible, but now the 1031 exchange needs to be set up with more attention in the planning phase. Generally, instead of the note being issued directly to the seller by the borrower, the qualified intermediary receives it as part of the relinquished property transaction. The QI is literally made the beneficiary under the note and is owed payments by that buyer-borrower.
This allows the note to exist out of constructive receipt and within the exchange, and the exchanger can avoid recognition for tax purposes at the time of the sale. But it also creates another problem to solve because the QI is now holding a promissory note. But the investor is trying to buy real estate, and a promissory note isn't liquid like cash. So the question becomes: how does that note become value that can actually be used to acquire the replacement property in the exchange?
And there are a few ways that might happen.
The cleanest example is that the buyer simply pays the note before the replacement property closes. Maybe it's short-term seller financing, and the buyer was waiting for another source of funds or capital to come in shortly after their purchase closed. In this scenario, the buyer pays off the balance of the note directly to the QI, who is the beneficiary. And now the QI has cash that can be used toward the exchanger's replacement property acquisition.
Simple conceptually, of course, the timing has to work. If the buyer's obligation isn't due until three years from now, and the investor needs to close on replacement property three months from now, that obviously creates a problem, which is why the term or the length of the seller financing matters to the exchange plan.
Another possibility is that the note gets sold. If the exchanger can find a third party that's willing to purchase that $300,000 note, the note is transferred from the QI, the third party pays cash for it, and that cash can then become available through the exchange to buy replacement property. But here's where real life shows up again. A $300,000 promissory note isn't automatically worth $300,000 to somebody who's being asked to buy it. The buyer of that note might look at factors like interest rate, the collateral, the payment history, the borrower's creditworthiness, and the amount of time before the loan gets paid off. And they might say, I'll buy that note, but I'll only pay $285,000 for it. They want a discount.
So now the exchanging investor has another economic decision to make. Selling the note creates liquidity so that they can purchase replacement property, but potentially at a discount. And the difference between the note's face value and the actual purchase price is likely taxable boot at the end of the exchange. So this scenario should be part of the questions an investor is asking during their planning phase of the exchange, not during.
Figuring out what your total liability is, how much you're willing to pay, and how much tax exposure would make the exchange maybe not even worth it. These are really important benchmarks to establish before you get to the point of trying to sell a note that's in an exchange to a third party who may require a discount.
There's another structure that sometimes surprises people. The exchanger may be able to use their own outside cash to purchase the note from the QI. Let's use the same $300,000 example. The QI holds the buyer's $300,000 promissory note. The exchanger brings in $300,000 of their own separate funds and purchases that note just before their replacement property needs funding. The exchanger now owns the note, and the QI now holds $300,000 in cash.
And that cash can be used toward the property purchase. So, in short, what happened economically here? The exchanger essentially moved $300,000 of outside capital into the exchange and received the promissory note in return. This is again a scenario where investors considering seller financing should talk with the QI and their tax and legal team early. An investor could be perfectly comfortable carrying the buyer's note and want to exchange.
But they may not have another $300,000 sitting outside of the exchange that they can use to buy it. That could completely change whether the path is actually realistic. Because finding a third-party buyer for the note may also be really challenging. And I want to stress that point because in discussing these paths, it's not really about which option is best for an investor-exchanger. They really should be thinking of this as a framework for a conversation with their advisor team on, A, whether a seller financing arrangement is even feasible, B, what the actual numbers are and how much wiggle room there is, and C, what their risk appetite is if the funds can't be replaced and the exchanger ends up with the note at the end of the exchange, anyways. One other question that comes up a lot when discussing the exchanger buying the note from the QI, if they have the cash, why not loan it directly to the buyer at closing and have the entire sales price sent to the QI as proceeds at the outset?
This does avoid the need for the QI to receive the note and have it converted to cash during the exchange. And this can be a great option, but investors need to think about the likelihood that they'll actually find a replacement property. Because think of this: if full proceeds are received by the QI and property isn't found and acquired, when the funds are released to the investor, they'd be fully taxable up to the capital gains exposure at that time. If the QI receives the note and the exchange fails, the note's assigned back to the investor.
And they might be able to preserve the option to report the income using the installment method over time, assuming the payments span several years. Again, this is a nuance that your tax advisor can help you understand better in the context of your financial picture.
There's one more possibility that's conceptually pretty interesting, even if it rarely happens in practice. The seller of the replacement property you identify could agree to accept the promissory note as part of the purchase price. So instead of the replacement seller receiving 100% cash, part of the consideration could be the note that originated with the buyer of the relinquished property. The QI would assign it to the seller on behalf of the exchanging investor, along with the transfer of the property to the investor.
And the borrower would make payments from that point forward to the replacement property seller as their new beneficiary. There are circumstances where this can work, but now the investors added another third party to the equation. The replacement property seller has to be willing to take someone else's note in this scenario. They'd have to be comfortable with that borrower, the note's terms, and any risk associated with not receiving cash at the sale. So while that option may technically exist, the practical question is whether the other side of the deal actually wants it. Something can be structurally possible and still be difficult to execute in a real transaction.
If you're thinking seller financing is a bad idea, it can be a very helpful tool for the right investor, but it does mean adding another moving piece. And 1031 exchanges already have plenty of moving pieces. Running through a few of the practical issues we've covered, we have: first, timing. If the note is inside the exchange and needs to become cash before your replacement property can be purchased, does the payment schedule actually allow that?
Second, liquidity. If the exchanging investor plans to buy the note from the QI, do they actually have the outside cash to do it? Third, marketability. If someone else is supposed to buy the note, is there really a buyer for it? And at what price? Fourth, credit risk. If the investor ultimately owns the note, how comfortable are they being this buyer's lender for the next several years? And fifth, documentation. Seller financing arrangements need to be raised with the QI before closing.
So that the exchange documents and flow of consideration actually match the structure the investor intends to use. These are all much easier questions to deal with while the purchase agreement is still being negotiated. They're much harder to address under the pressure of time when everybody is already sitting at the closing table, ready to go.
To really break this down into something practical, if you're selling investment real estate and your buyer asks you to carry part of the purchase price, here are five questions I'd have on my list as an investor. Number one, do I actually want to be this buyer's lender? Think about the economics of the note itself: the interest rate, security, as in, can you get your property back if they default? The payment schedule, maturity, and the risk that the buyer doesn't pay when expected.
Secondly, how long am I willing to wait to receive the money? That matters in any seller financing arrangement, but it matters even more if you're expecting to use that value to acquire another property in a 1031 exchange. Number three, am I planning to do a 1031 exchange? And if the answer is yes, raise that with all appropriate parties before the sale closes. Number four, do I expect the note to stay outside of the exchange or be part of the exchange?
That's the big fork in the road, so to speak, in the 1031 conversation. Do you want to take that note as boot and report the installment payments over time, or do you want the opportunity to defer the gain? The consequences of either path should be discussed with your tax advisor. Number five, if the note goes into the exchange, what's the plan for it? Here's where you really sit down with your QI representative or exchange officer and your tax advisors to flesh out the plan.
Is the buyer going to pay it off during the exchange? Will somebody buy it? Again, do you have the outside cash available to purchase it yourself? If so, does it make more sense to loan the buyer the cash at closing if you feel confident you've found a replacement property to buy? Or do you want added flexibility by retaining the note within the exchange? Is a replacement property seller actually willing to accept the note as payment?
This is not a fully inclusive list, and you don't have to answer all these questions before you figure out whether you're going to include seller financing in the exchange, but you do want to recognize the question early enough to plan escape routes or find the answer with efficiency during the 1031 exchange transaction. Seller financing can be a really useful real estate tool. It may bridge a financing gap. It may create more flexibility for a buyer and a seller. And depending on the facts, it may create installment sale planning opportunities that the seller can discuss with their CPA.
But when seller financing overlaps with the 1031 exchange, there's one extra question that needs to be answered before closing. Where does the note go? Once you know that, you can start figuring out what the exchange actually needs to look like. We'll link a simple seller financing FAQ in the show notes. You can use it as a starting point for conversations with your own qualified intermediary, tax advisor, and legal counsel. Thanks for listening to The 1031 Brief.
We'll see you next time, bringing you information useful enough to remember and practical enough to use.
This podcast is for educational purposes only and isn't legal, tax, financial, or investment advice. Please consult your own tax advisor and legal counsel about your situation.
This episode is copyright 2026 by First American Financial Corporation, all rights reserved.
This transcript has been edited for clarity.
Check out more episodes of The 1031 Brief.
