What’s the Outlook for Housing Market Potential for the Rest of 2019?

Written by First American Chief Economist, Mark Fleming

In September 2019, the housing market performed to its potential, as actual existing-home sales were a marginal 0.04 percent, or an estimated 2,340 seasonally adjusted annualized sales, below market potential. Housing market potential decreased relative to last month, but increased 3.8 percent compared with September of last year. Indeed, in September of last year, rising mortgage rates dampened market potential and existing-home sales underperformed market potential by 7.2 percent, or an estimated 445,200 sales. The market dynamics and outlook has improved significantly in the last 12 months, begging the question: what’s changed?

“Lower mortgage rates have a dual effect on the housing market: they incentivize homeowners to move as the rate 'lock-in' effect fades and they boost demand by making homes more affordable.”

Then vs. Now

In September 2018, the 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage was 4.63 percent and reached a high of 4.87 percent in November. Today, mortgage rates are more than one percentage point lower than one year ago, and 1.26 percentage points lower than the November 2018 zenith. In September of last year, rates were forecasted to continue to rise, as many experts believed the Federal Reserve would continue to increase the Federal Funds rate and put more upward pressure on mortgage rates. Rising rates reduce home-buying power and decrease market potential for existing-home sales.

But, in December 2018, the unexpected happened – volatility in the bond market helped drive mortgage rates lower. This trend has continued through most of 2019 and mortgage rates are now near historically low levels. Lower mortgage rates have a dual effect on the housing market: they incentivize homeowners to move as the rate “lock-in” effect fades, which slows or reduces the average tenure of homeowners, and they boost demand by making homes more affordable.

Drag on Market Potential from Tenure Length Reduced Dramatically

Changes in tenure length are largely the result of the strength of the rate “lock-in” effect, and seniors aging in place. The year-over-year growth in tenure length has been slowing since March of this year and it is conceivable that it could stabilize or even decline, if mortgage rates continue to trend lower. In September 2019, the impact of increasing tenure length on market potential resulted in a loss of 137,230 potential home sales, but that is dramatically less than the 421,260 in September of last year.

Affordability Boosts Market Potential

In 2019, housing affordability benefitted from lower mortgage rates and higher incomes driven by the strong labor market. In September 2019, house-buying power increased to $420,250, 15 percent higher than one year ago. The boost to house-buying power increased the market potential by 415,090 home sales, more than 10 times the annual gain in market potential boost of just 34,390 potential home sales in September 2018.

Then vs. Now

What’s the Outlook for the Rest of 2019?

Housing is the most durable consumer good we’ll ever buy, and surging house-buying power fuels greater potential demand. You can’t buy what’s not for sale, but rising existing-home sales means more homes on the market, helping to meet the growing demand. While several factors may trigger a directional switch for market potential, the current environment of low mortgage rates and wage growth driven by a strong labor market, supports a healthy housing market for the remainder of 2019.